I offer you this sunny photo of one of my favorite dogwalking areas as proof that I’m not about to slit my wrists or quit writing or anything so dire.

Yes, Nice Agent rejected my latest manuscript one week ago today. At the time I felt bummed and angry. Bummed because apparently he’s not the agent for me, and, thus, I must start the agent-hunting process all over again. Is there such a thing as trying-to-get-published fatigue? I suppose that’s me.
You might ask yourself why Nice Agent can’t still be my agent. So he didn’t fall in love with this manuscript, so what? This is where the angry part comes in. I couldn’t believe the rejection letter he sent me! I am/was a client, after all, and what did he send me but a generic rejection letter! As if my manuscript had come off the slush pile or something! I was steamed about this, to be sure. (Three exclamation points in one paragraph; that’s a record for me — ! — and make that four.)
I don’t take rejection letters personally anymore, yet, last week I was offended. (And I don’t offend easily.) I mean, hello? Do not send me a boilerplate rejection letter with a few pat compliments and then the usual spiel about the competitive marketplace and how you need to be head over heels for a project to be its best advocate and etcetera. As a so-called client, I deserved more than that.
And my God, I’m not an idiot. I know a blow off when I read one. Yes, blow off, because the one thing that he could have written to indicate his continued interest in my writing would have been something like: I’m interested in reading further works; please consider me…etcetera.
But no. So, me thinks Nice Agent is Erstwhile Agent #2.
However, I didn’t let him get away with such a response, not entirely. I replied in a polite yet straightfoward manner, thanking him, pointing out his generic letter, and asking as a kinda-client for more details. I asked him to provide his overall impression of my writing and his opinion about what I need to work on to improve my stories (which is to say, make them more salable).
All this is subjective, I know, but he responded (nicely) with the answer I thought I’d hear: plot/pacing. My stories are too leisurely for his taste.
I’m going to look for a new agent for the two finished manuscripts, don’t get me wrong — they ARE worthwhile and entertaining stories with plots – but I’m also going to ponder pacing. I doubt I’ll ever be a wham-bam-thank-you-’mam kind of writer, but I probably do have more to learn…sigh…










Keep at it! Don’t give up! There must be an agent out there for you!
And good thing you put your current agent into place
By: thegirlinthecafe on June 22, 2009
at 1:43 pm
I find it awful that in order to make your works salable they have to be less “leisurely.” But I suppose it’s a tendency of our time, because no one takes time to read good stories, only thrillers. And if you write something not explicitly a “thriller,” it still has to have at least the pacing of a thriller.
And we always here from publishers and agents that if a story doesn’t capture you in the first page it’s not going to get published. How many people would have rejected anything “good” written in the 19th and early 20th centuries?
Sucks. I feel for ya. Good luck elsewhere, I guess.
By: filthylogician on June 22, 2009
at 2:01 pm
Oh…
UGH.
Just UGH.
My words are failing me right now. I’m so sorry, Lisa.
(This guy isn’t the same as my guy, is it? I think not, but just asking.)
Okay… you will find someone else. AND you have two manuscripts to query with. That is so great. You can get started tomorrow! If you wrote YA I could recommend someone from all my recent research, but I’m at a loss now for adult. Feel free to email me to vent, always, okay?
By: nova on June 22, 2009
at 3:19 pm
Crapp. That’s right. Crap with a double P. I’m ready for a drink/venting/pep talk whenever you are.
By: tracer on June 22, 2009
at 8:46 pm
Do not be swayed by his response. Continue to be who you are, write your stories. It will happen.
Enjoy your life. I love that photo of your Buddha dog. Embrace that spirit.
By: Caroline on June 23, 2009
at 5:33 am
Hey Lisa, wanted to throw out an invitation your way to the The Cabin. You came down a long long long time ago. We are headed north this Sunday and will be up your way until about the 15th of July. I always try to head up to Portland and look everyone up, however cabin life has a way of sucking me in and leaving is nearly impossible. So I thought I would extend the invitation to you and see if you’d like to come live the river life for a weekend, few days whatever you can spare. I’d love to catch up and chat.
By: Liz on June 24, 2009
at 7:32 pm
Have you considered self-publishing?
By: Phillip S Phogg on June 25, 2009
at 4:20 pm
well that just sucks – and i know what you mean about the blow off-y-ness of the rejection letter. i think your instincts are probably correct about it not being a good fit and its great you are following your guts.
in the meantime, yuk!!!!!!!!
By: sambycat on June 26, 2009
at 5:30 am
So sorry, Lisa, but I think you’re right to just move on (after allowing yourself some good venting.) And I’m so glad you wrote back to N.A. and asked for more clarification–and got it! I’m a little tired, too, of the “leisurely” plot being something that’s not valued! We don’t ALL want to read things that go at a breakneck pace! Please don’t give up. These will be the stories you’ll tell at your readings some day, and the audience will gasp and say, “Really?!?!?! People didn’t always appreciate your work???”
By: sandi shelton on June 28, 2009
at 4:22 pm
I feel for you, Lisa, I really do…but at least you’ve had an agent (or two). And I love the way you responded. Firm and professional. Good for you!
I know you’ll keep at it, and I wish you the best of luck in finding a good match for your style of writing.
By the way, I LOVE that dog-walking spot.
By: Tanya Mills on June 30, 2009
at 5:59 pm
Oh Lisa, this is SUCH A DRAG! You are right to respond first, and then to decide to move on. Your books will find a home; of that I’m sure.
As for finding an agent, e-mail me if you want and I will be happy to send you the loooooonnnngggg list I used in finding mine.
xoxoxo
By: bloglily on July 4, 2009
at 11:15 pm
I’m worried that agents are specialists anymore. I mean, I don’t expect that to be Max Perkins but I do rather expect them to be more writing-intensive on coaxing damn good writers along. Seems to me he’s looking for an easy fix in a pop trash world.
And he would do well to widen his “best seller” horizons.
There. That’s my rant.
I LOVE leisurely stories. Not that long ago, there was time to tell a story. Believe me, you have something to get out there and get it out there you will.
Just wish I knew someone to connect with you in publishing.
And it wouldn’t be me writing to you if I didn’t comment on the photo you included – which is lovely. And hello to Luna!
By: oh on July 5, 2009
at 7:52 am
Joe Konrath – who was rejected for 12 years following the rules of literary agents (only solicit one at a time, wait 2-3 months before they reject you, etc.) tells the story of getting an agent but just going whole hog and soliciting dozens at once. 10-12 wanted to read his manuscript, 3-4 wanted to represent him, he interviewed them and picked one, ended up with a six-figure advance for 3-book deal. (Apologies to Joe if I am not remembering this perfectly.) So my point is, keep at it!
By: literarylunchbox on August 1, 2009
at 8:20 am